Shows Reviewed in 2025
Click on a show title below to access our review. If the title is not linked, we have not published a review of this show. Follow us on social media (links in upper right), and we will post when new reviews are published!
View Critic’s Picks
Legend:
⭐️ PreviewNight.com Critic’s Pick
✅ Good production; enjoyed the show
➖ Mixed experience
❌ Disappointed
🚧 Preview performance not quite yet ready for review
| Rating | Date | Show Title | Venue |
|---|---|---|---|
| ⭐️ | 12/20/25 | Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) | Longacre Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 12/20/25 | Maybe Happy Ending | Belasco Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 12/19/25 | Just In Time | Circle in the Square Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 12/19/25 | Beau the Musical | The Distillery |
| ⭐️ | 12/19/25 | Gruesome Playground Injuries) | Lucille Lortel Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 12/18/25 | Ragtime | Vivian Beaumont Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 12/18/25 | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | New World Stages |
| ⭐️ | 12/17/25 | This World of Tomorrow | The Shed |
| ✅ | 12/16/25 | Harry Potter and the Cursed Child | Lyric Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 12/15/25 | The Bridges of Madison County (OBC Reunion Benefit Concert) | MCC Theatre at Carnegie Hall |
| ✅ | 12/15/25 | Christmas Spectacular Starring The Radio City Rockettes | Radio City Music Hall |
| ⭐️ | 12/14/25 | Little Shop of Horrors | Westside Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 12/14/25 | Hadestown | Walter Kerr Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 12/6/25 | Disney's The Lion King (National Tour) | Paramount Theatre (Seattle) |
| ⭐️ | 12/3/25 | Come From Away (Opening Night) | Seattle Rep |
| 🚧 | 11/28/25 | Elf the Musical (First Preview) | The 5th Avenue Theatre (Seattle) |
| 11/26/25 | Come From Away (Tech Dress Rehearsal) | Seattle Rep | |
| ✅ | 11/9/25 | Shucked (National Tour) | Paramount Theatre (Seattle) |
| ⭐️ | 11/1/25 | Mexodus (Closing Performance) | Minetta Lane Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 11/1/25 | Bay Boy: The Musical | New York City Center |
| ⭐️ | 10/26/25 | Fancy Dancer | Seattle Rep |
| ✅ | 10/25/25 | Godspell | inD Theatre |
| ✅ | 10/25/25 | Chicago (National Tour) | The 5th Avenue Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 10/10/25 | Ragtime (Preview) | Lincoln Center Theater at the Vivian Beaumont |
| ⭐️ | 10/9/25 | Kyoto (Preview) | Lincoln Center Theater at the Mitzi E. Newhouse |
| ⭐️ | 10/8/25 | Liberation (First Preview) | James Earl Jones Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 10/8/25 | Art | The Music Box |
| 🚧 | 10/7/25 | Oh Happy Day! (Preview) | The Public Theater |
| ⭐️ | 10/6/25 | Mexodus | Minetta Lane Theatre |
| ✅ | 10/5/25 | Masquerade | 218 West 57th Street |
| ⭐️ | 10/5/25 | Caroline | MCC Theater |
| ⭐️ | 9/28/25 | An Enemy of the People | Union Arts Center (Seattle) |
| ⭐️ | 9/24/25 | Fancy Dancer (Opening Night) | Seattle Rep |
| ⭐️ | 9/23/25 | The Play That Goes Wrong | Seattle Rep |
| ⭐️ | 9/21/25 | Suffs (National Tour) | The 5th Avenue Theatre (Seattle) |
| ➖ | 9/19/25 | Brigadoon (Opening Night) | Village Theatre (Issaquah, WA) |
| 🚧 | 9/12/25 | The Other Americans (Preview) | The Public Theater |
| ⭐️ | 9/11/25 | The Outsiders | Bernard B. Jacobs Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 9/10/25 | Punch (Preview) | Manhattan Theatre Club at the Samuel J. Friedman Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 9/9/25 | Cabaret | Kit Kat Club at The August Wilson Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 9/6/25 | Death Becomes Her | Lunt-Fontanne Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 9/6/25 | John Proctor is the Villain | Booth Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 9/5/25 | Twelfth Night | Delacorte Theater |
| 8/27/25 | The Play That Goes Wrong (Tech Dress Rehearsal) | Seattle Rep | |
| ⭐️ | 8/8/25 | After Midnight (Opening Night) | The 5th Avenue Theatre (Seattle) |
| ✅ | 8/3/25 | & Juliet (National Tour) | Paramount Theatre (Seattle) |
| ✅ | 7/25/25 | Sondheim Tribute Revue | Ovation! Performing Arts Northwest at Side Quest Stage at Rolling Bay Hall (Bainbridge Island) |
| ⭐️ | 7/18/25 | Wicked | Gershwin Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 7/17/25 | Hell's Kitchen | Sam S. Shubert Theatre |
| ✅ | 7/17/25 | The Play That Goes Wrong | New World Stages |
| ⭐️ | 7/16/25 | Operation Mincemeat | Golden Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 7/16/25 | Hadestown | Walter Kerr Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 7/15/25 | Hamilton | Richard Rodgers Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 7/14/25 | JOY (Preview) | Laura Pels Theatre at the Harold and Miriam Steinberg Center for Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 7/13/25 | Purpose | The Hayes Theater |
| ⭐️ | 6/29/25 | Wicked (National Tour) | Old National Centre (Indianapolis) |
| ✅ | 6/21/25 | Twelfth Night | ACT Theatre and Seattle Shakespeare Company |
| ❌ | 6/14/25 | Mamma Mia! (National Tour) | Paramount Theatre (Seattle) |
| ⭐️ | 6/12/25 | Just In Time | Circle in the Square |
| ⭐️ | 6/11/25 | Sunset Blvd. | St. James Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 6/11/25 | Maybe Happy Ending | Belasco Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 6/10/25 | Sexual Misconduct of the Middle Classes | Minetta Lane Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 6/9/25 | Oh, Mary! | Lyceum Theatre |
| ✅ | 6/8/25 | Good Night, and Good Luck (Closing Performance) | Winter Garden Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 6/7/25 | Gypsy | Majestic Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 6/7/25 | Sondheim's Old Friends | Manhattan Theatre Club at the Samuel J. Friedman Theatre |
| ⭐️ | 6/6/25 | SMASH | Imperial Theatre |
| ✅ | 5/23/25 | Eddie Izzard Hamlet | Seattle Rep |
| ✅ | 5/16/25 | The SpongeBob Musical | Bainbridge Performing Arts (Bainbridge Island) |
| ✅ | 5/10/25 | SIX (National Tour) | Paramount Theatre (Seattle) |
| ✅ | 5/9/25 | Grease | Bainbridge High School (Bainbridge Island) |
| ✅ | 5/1/25 | Golden | ACT Theatre (Seattle) |
| ✅ | 4/30/25 | Laughs in Spanish | Seattle Rep |
| ✅ | 4/20/25 | Parade (National Tour) | The 5th Avenue Theatre (Seattle) |
| ⭐️ | 4/17/25 | Life of Pi (National Tour) | Paramount Theatre (Seattle) |
| ⭐️ | 3/30/25 | Waitress | The 5th Avenue Theatre (Seattle) |
| ✅ | 3/6/25 | Eurydice | Bainbridge Performing Arts (Bainbridge Island) |
| ✅ | 2/11/25 | Hamilton (National Tour) | Paramount Theatre (Seattle) |
| ✅ | 2/6/25 | MagPie | Bainbridge Performing Arts (Bainbridge Island) |
| ⭐️ | 1/24/25 | Dial M for Murder | Village Theatre (Issaquah, WA) |
| ✅ | 1/7/25 | Kimberly Akimbo (National Tour) | Paramount Theatre (Seattle) |